Tigers tell Benji: We’ve moved on

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

WESTS Tigers have a blunt message for Benji Marshall: We have moved on.

Marshall has stunned the league world by declaring he wants to return to the NRL after seeking a release from his Super Rugby contract with the Auckland Blues.

When he announced in July last year he was quitting the Tigers to chase a lucrative contract in Super Rugby, Marshall declared: "I will honour my words about not playing for another (NRL) club. There is no other NRL club for me to play for. The Tigers are my home and will always be my home."

Benji Marshall given a guard of honour for his last home. Source: News Limited

Now he won't have a choice after the Tigers ruled out an emotional return to the club for their former star.

"At the moment we have made some decisions on the back of his decision last year (to leave),'' Wests Tigers CEO Grant Mayer said.

"Unfortunately there's no room in our top 25 for Benji Marshall next year.

"He made a decision and we have to move on.

"I think there is a genuine love and affection for Benji, there's no doubt the fans will be asking the question (about a return).

"But I think we have made a pretty strong statement this year in regards to the kids coming through.

"No doubt our plan is for our kids to come through."

Benji Marshall farewells the crowd after his last home. Source: News Limited

Mayer will meet this week with the manager of young five-eighth Curtis Sironen.

Other rising kids Mitchell Moses, Luke Brooks and David Nofoaluma have recently re-signed, the club hoping injured fullback James Tedesco will be retained shortly.

Pressed on whether his club had 'moved on' from Marshall, Mayer said: "He is always a big part of our past. We said that when he left. He helped build the club.

"We wish him the best on behalf of our board and all our fans.

"Let me say I am surprised to hear that he has left the Blues. I know he was very excited about taking up a new challenge.

"I know he is happy in New Zealand, he bought a house over there so I wouldn't be surprised if he stayed there but there are always rumours about Super League."

What do you think of Benji's decision to quit rugby?

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

Eels accuse Brooks of taking a dive

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

ANGRY Parramatta coach Brad Arthur accused young Wests Tigers star Luke Brooks of taking a dive to prevent the Eels scoring a decisive try in Monday's massive match at ANZ Stadium.

In front of 50,668 fans, Wests Tigers and Parramatta engaged in an enthralling and vigorous game which again though was marred by the obstruction rule.

"It's a lottery," said Eels champion Jarryd Hayne.

Tigers Luke Brooks watches his field goal go over. Source: News Corp Australia

With his side behind 18-14, Parramatta centre Will Hopoate scored what appeared a legimtiate try, which was approved by referee Matt Cecchin.

However video referees Steve Clark and Andrew Dunemann controversially over-ruled Cecchin after watching Parramatta forward David Gower allegedly obstruct Brooks, who fell to the ground.

"I don't know what an obstruction is anymore," Arthur said. "As coaches, we'll start to encourage our players to take a dive.

"Dave Gower clearly got back at his (Brooks) inside shoulder.

"The rule is you've got to get back on the inside shoulder and that's what Dave Gower did. He went through the line sideways."

Will Hopoate goes in but the try was disallowed after video ref ruled obstruction. Source: News Corp Australia

Hayne was vocal at fulltime, confused and bewildered at the decision.

"I think the players, the fans, the coaches just want consistency," Hayne said. "Every week it seems like it's changing.

"As soon as it gets a media storm they get a bit of fear behind them, the video refs, and it's a lottery.

"It's pretty clear that Gower didn't take him out.

"If that's going to be the rules then stay with it. Don't come back next week (after a) media storm ... they start to getting scared again.

"As players when you're looking at it you are going 'it's sweet'. I'm sure if you ask some of the Tigers boys they'll say the same thing. We just want consistency. We're not asking too much."

Hayne claimed the obstruction rule was "frustrating".

Parramatta's Jarryd Hayne argues a call with the referee. Source: News Corp Australia

Asked were players confused, Hayne said: "Definitely. In the past that's a try.

"That can be the rule now — where someone can touch the other player and fall down and it's ruled a penalty — then so be it.

"Let's just keep consistent and on the same page and not change it a week, two weeks after. That's what's frustrating the most."

Brooks though was quick to dismal talk he took a dive.

Wests Tigers celebrate their victory. Source: News Corp Australia

"No, I don't think so," he said. "He ran into me. I couldn't do anything else.

"I thought it (the video referee decision) was 50/50. It was lucky it was called a no-try."

The drama could not though overshadow a cracking day at ANZ Stadium.

Two western Sydney teams went at it, the result was close, the crowd was massive.

The NRL has been marred by issues this year but yesterday helped us remember why the game is loved by many.

Parramatta always looked as though they would pinch the game but Wests Tigers somehow hung in there and snatched the two competition points.

Hayne scored two tries and set up another with a gorgeous kick to winger Ken Sio in another stellar performance.

Tigers fans cheer their team onto the field. Source: Getty Images

The scores were locked 18-all before Brooks kicked the crucial field goal to give his side a lead. Winger Pat Richards landed a penalty goal on fulltime for a 21-18 win.

Wests Tigers played yesterday without stars Robbie Farah, James Tedesco and Liam Fulton.

"It wasn't our prettiest win but I am happy to get the two points," said Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter.

"We showed a lot of grit and determination. It was a fantastic effort although we were far from our best in execution and defence."

Arthur lamented the defeat.

"At the end of the day, we needed to be better to win the game," he said. "They scored two tries off our errors."

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

Panthers hold on to knock Titans off

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

A FIRED-UP Jamal Idris last night inspired Penrith to a spiteful win over Gold Coast, a result that sparked rare congestion atop the NRL ladder.

In a match that will test the NRL's new lifting tackle guidelines, the Panthers brought the table-topping Titans back to the field with a 14-12 victory before 9,555 nervous fans.

Josh Mansour tries to escape the clutches of Nate Myles and Dave Taylor. Source: Getty Images

Determined to prove a point against his former team mates, Idris was near unstoppable in the first stanza as the hosts held a deserved 12-6 half-time lead.

But despite plenty of possession, Penrith couldn't post another try and were forced to endure a jittery final minute after Aiden Sezer scored a late four-pointer to set up a chilling finale.

The match finished with Gold Coast pounding Penrith's line, and the result only assured when Albert Kelly's last ditch kick sailed harmlessly into the arms of Josh Mansour.

Jamal Idris ducops a big one from his former team. Source: News Corp Australia

The loss brings Gold Coast back to four-way tie for first, while Penrith now sit with four other rivals, just one win adrift of the apex.

The Titans could also be without Matt White for an extended period, after the prop was placed on report for a clear dangerous throw on Adam Docker. The 61st minute infringement sparked hostilities, which continued in the dying stages when Sika Manu lashed out at Greg Bird after accusing the Titans co-captain of applying a squirrel grip.

Greg Bird gets to grips with Sika Manu. Source: FoxSports

A Gold Coast try just before the break kept the contest alive after Penrith had dominated the first 40 minutes with their hard running and free-flowing attitude.

Making their third straight appearance on home turf, the Panthers desperately needed to win ahead of a marathon road trip that won't return them to the foot of the mountains until 30 May.

They were also chastened from last Friday night's try-less effort against the Rabbitohs, finding the stripe after just seven minutes as the Titans struggled for early intensity.

Matt White went on report for this dangerous tackle. Source: FoxSports

Jamie Soward set-up the four-pointer with a lovely double pump pass that saw Dean Whare outpace former team mate Maurice Blair. The pumped-up pivot converted from out wide, but, despite running their opponents ragged, was forced to wait until the half-hour mark for another attempt.

The second Panthers try came in near comical circumstances, with David Mead and Paul Carter botching an innocuous Soward grubber. In a panicked bid to keep the ball from Soward's grasp, Carter could only watch in horror as he mis-kicked it into the grateful grasp of Penrith fullback Matt Moylan.

'Dean Whare opened the scoring for the Panthers. Source: News Corp Australia

With Idris and Peter Wallace slicing and dicing the Titans at will, Penrith looked set to seal the game before half-time. But then came Gold Coast's shock reply, which saw Ryan James awarded a 37th minute barge-over try in the face of protests from Penrith defenders who claimed he'd been held-up.

PENRITH 14 (M Moylan D Whare tries J Soward 3 goals) bt GOLD COAST 12 (R James A Sezer tries A Sezer 2 goals) at Sportingbet Stadium. Referee: Gavin Morris, Gavin Reynolds. Crowd: 9,555.

YOU RATE THE TITANS

Relive the action from a massive Easter Monday in our matchday blog.

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

The Barometer: Round 6

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

INJURIES

Brad Crouch (leg) 3 weeks

Ricky Henderson (ankle) 3-4 months

Jack Osborn (back) 3 weeks

Andy Otten (knee) test

Nathan van Berlo (Achilles) 3-5 months

Taylor Walker (knee) 3-4 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Hard to pick on any Crows involved in the 11-goal demolition of Greater Western Sydney. Substitute Tom Lynch will need to put in a power of work to avoid the vest, while Sam Kerridge was less than convincing against the Giants.

DOUGLAS BUMP TO COME UNDER SCRUTINY

ON THE CUSP: Key forward Lewis Johnston did his chances no harm kicking four goals in Adelaide's SANFL win over Central Districts. Mitch Grigg and Jarryd Lyons were prolific in the midfield while Andy Otten collected 24 disposals. Shaun McKernan moved well as did veteran forward Jason Porplyzia.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: The next two games are critical with winnable fixtures against Western Bulldogs (Etihad) and Melbourne (Adelaide Oval). The inconsistent Crows must split to remain in touch with the top eight, while two wins could get West Lakes buzzing ahead of the Round 9 bye. Patrick Dangerfield's blistering return to form was something else, as was Matt Crouch's ball-winning ability prior to being subbed off with cramps.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

BRISBANE

INJURIES

Claye Beams (foot) 2 weeks

Josh Green (hamstring) 1 week

Pearce Hanley (hamstring) test

Matthew Leuenberger (knee) 13 weeks

Stefan Martin (back) test

Ash McGrath (calf) test

Daniel Merrett (suspension) 1 week

Daniel Rich (knee) season

Brent Staker (calf) indefinite

Patrick Weardon (ankle) 11 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Luke McGuane did his best work after the siren — chairing Jonathan Brown off the ground after his 250th game. He had a stinker, just the four disposals and three free kicks against. Jordan Lisle struggled in defence, while Jackson Paine was substituted out of the match with just three disposals.

SPOON LOOMS LARGE FOR LIONS

ON THE CUSP: Tom Rockliff hinted on Monday that Pearce Hanley could return ahead of schedule if he passes a fitness test this week. Daniel Merrett makes a welcome return from suspension while Andrew Raines was best on ground for the twos and James Polkinghorne slotted four goals in the win over Aspley. Ryan Hardwood could push for selection along with Jono Freeman.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Brisbane threatened but lacked the class to go with Richmond, and it's not going be any easier against St Kilda in Wellington on Anzac Day. Tom Rockliff and Jonathan Brown hold the keys for Brisbane, while Lewis Taylor is on the cusp of a breakout performance.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

CARLTON

INJURIES

Chris Judd (Hamstring) 5 weeks

Tom Bell (finger) 3-4 weeks

Ed Curnow (fibula) 6 weeks

Michael Jamison (shoulder) test

Matthew Kreuzer (foot) 10-12 weeks

Troy Menzel (hamstring) test

ON THE BLOCK: Despite the Blues' spirited first win of 2014 against the Western Bulldogs, the post-match discussion has surrounded Chris Judd, who injured his right hamstring only six minutes into his comeback from an Achilles injury. He is expected to miss at least five weeks. Will 2014 be his last hurrah? The news was not good either for Ed Curnow, who suffered a fourth-term leg injury after crashing into a behind post and will miss six weeks. Tom Bell will be another forced change while Sam Rowe (five touches) and David Ellard (eight) potentially have a nervous wait before Carlton's match committee meets this week.

JUDD INJURY WON'T LEAVE BLUES HAMSTRUNG

ON THE CUSP: With Judd miss until after Carlton's bye, a spot now opens up in the Blues' midfield. Veteran Brock McLean is a strong chance to claim it after a stellar performance for the Northern Blues in the VFL. McLean gathered 24 touches, as well as 11 clearances, 10 tackles and six inside-50s in his second consecutive best-on-ground performance for the Blues. Nick Graham was also good, finishing with 25 disposals. Out-of-favour forward Jeff Garlett booted two goals and laid six tackles, while Matthew Watson impressed at full-back. Michael Jamison (shoulder) and Troy Menzel (hamstring) will be monitored throughout the week.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: Monday morning is always much sweeter when your team wins on the weekend. This has never been truer for Blues fans, as the victory against the Bulldogs on Sunday has released a significant amount of pressure. What was most pleasing for coach Mick Malthouse was the form of Carlton's big men, with Lachie Henderson and Jarrad Waite booting eight goals between them and ruckman Robbie Warnock playing arguably his best game for the club. If the Blues produce the same grit and determination against the Eagles next Saturday, a second straight win is not beyond them.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

COLLINGWOOD

INJURIES

Tim Broomhead (shin splints) test

Nathan Brown (shoulder) test

Sam Dwyer (knee) test

Nathan Freeman (hamstring) 3 weeks

Adam Oxley (ankle) 1 week

Ben Reid (calf) 1 week

Matthew Scharenberg (feet) indefinite

Paul Seedsman (hip) test

Ben Sinclair (hamstring) 1 week

ON THE BLOCK: Hard to see any Pies getting the chop after their sterling four-quarter demolition of North Melbourne. First-year defender Tom Langdon looks ready for spell, while Jarrod Witts could find himself on the outer should Nathan Buckley want to inject run into his Anzac Day game plan.

SHARP MAGPIES A WORK IN PROGRESS

ON THE CUSP: Key defender Nathan Brown (shoulder) emerged unscathed from his VFL comeback match, while Sam Dwyer was best afield in the Magpies' comprehensive win over Coburg. Taylor Adams and Kyle Martin showed plenty and must be considered, while Patrick Karnezis booted three goals.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Write off the Magpies at your peril. Nathan Buckley's squad fired on all cylinders against North. The midfield juggernaut purred, while Travis Cloke made All-Australian defender Scott Thompson look pedestrian in one-on-one contests. After a torrid start (Geelong and Fremantle in the first three rounds) the stage is set for the Magpies (3-2) with games against Essendon and Carlton ahead of their Round 9 bye. We know Essendon lifts for Anzac Day, but the Magpies have won three of the past five instalments — get on!

Magpie Nathan Brown all strapped up at training. Picture: Getty Source: Getty Images

ESSENDON

INJURIES

Patrick Ambrose (quad) 1 week

Tom Bellchambers (ankle) test

Alex Browne (knee) season

Corey Dell'Olio (suspension) 2 weeks

Courtenay Dempsey (hamstring) 1 week

Brendon Goddard (groin) test

Will Hams (hip) 2 weeks

Nick Kommer (knee) 1 week

Kyle Hardingham (leg) test

Heath Hocking (hand) test

Jason Winderlich (rested) available

ON THE BLOCK: Kyle Hardingham (50 per cent efficiency) might find himself on the outer after the Bombers' shock loss to St Kilda. Heath Hocking was subbed out with a hand problem.

WE WEREN'T READY: BOMBER

ON THE CUSP: Jason Winderlich will slot back into the Bombers' line-up after being given a week off to rest his body. Brendon Goddard will be put through his paces this week ahead of Friday's blockbuster. Kurt Aylett was the pick of the Bombers' reserves, while Tom Bellchambers kicked a goal in his VFL comeback from ankle surgery.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Where did that performance come from? The Bombers were simply outplayed for three quarters and had it not been for a couple of junk-time goals the scoreboard would look even worse. Anzac Day is a whole different story, it wouldn't matter if Essendon was defeated by 150 points last week, the Bombers will rise to the occasion. Looking forward to watching big-game specialist Paul Chapman in action for the first time on April 25, while Winderlich and Goddard — if fit — provide star quality required to upset Collingwood. This is going to be a corker … fingers crossed!

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

FREMANTLE

INJURIES

Michael Walters (ankle) season

Michael Barlow (knee) 3 weeks

Kepler Bradley (knee) 1 week

Max Duffy (shoulder) 5 weeks

Scott Gumbleton (hamstring) 7 weeks

Garrick Ibbotson (shoulder) test

Sam Menegola (knee) 5 weeks

Alex Pearce (shin) 1 week

Tanner Smith (hamstring) 4 weeks

Michael Wood (shoulder) test

ON THE BLOCK: Matt Taberner could find himself back in the WAFL after being subbed out against Sydney. Substitute Nick Suban is no certainty, while Cam Sutcliffe operated at just 60 per cent efficiency.

DOCKER SIMPSON 'DROPPED HIS BUNDLE'

ON THE CUSP: Tommy Sheridan racked up 32 disposals in Peel Thunder's loss to East Fremantle. Garrick Ibbotson was solid off half-back in the WAFL while comeback kid Anthony Morabito collected 19 disposals including five inside-50s.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Are the Dockers vulnerable? Surely not … but it raises the question: do they have enough depth to cover a mounting injury toll? What Michael Barlow lacks in Nat Fyfe-style pizzazz he makes up for sheer grunt. Michael Walters is another sorely missed in the forward line. This weekend's result depends on which North Melbourne turns up, but as long as the Dockers' Big 4 (Pavlich, Mundy, Sandilands and Fyfe) are anywhere near their best they'll have enough firepower to account for the Kangaroos.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

GEELONG

INJURIES

Mitch Brown (ankle) test

Allen Christensen (back) 5-6 weeks

Shane Kersten (knee) 6-8 weeks

Andrew Mackie (hamstring) 2-3 weeks

Daniel Menzel (knee) indefinite

Steven Motlop (knee) 1-2 weeks

Billie Smedts (leg fracture) 6 weeks

Nathan Vardy (knee) season

Zack Bates (hamstring) indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: Jackson Sheringham had limited game time after replacing Andrew Mackie, who was subbed out after an injury scare the previous week. George Burbury (11 disposals) and Travis Varcoe (10) could be nervous if Chris Scott wants to make some changes for Sunday's clash against Port Adelaide.

ON THE CUSP: Josh Walker (four goals) was Geelong's best at VFL level while young defenders Joel Hamling and Jake Kolodjashnij also impressed against Box Hill. The highlight for the Cats was the return of Steven Motlop from a knee injury; he kicked one goal after spending the first quarter on the bench. "It was a good physical hitout for me," Motlop told the Cats website. "I didn't come out trying to do anything tricky, I just tried to keep it basic. The next two days are pretty important to see how my knees pull up, but I don't feel too bad at the moment."

AL PATON'S FORECAST: Ageing list, host of injuries, undefeated and a game clear on top of the ladder after Round 5. Can anything stop the Cats? Port Adelaide at a packed Adelaide Oval on Sunday will be another challenge especially on a shorter break after a heavyweight clash against the Hawks, but you wouldn't back against them.

ROUND 5: IF YOU DON'T MIND UMPIRE!

GOLD COAST

INJURIES

Harley Bennell (calf) 1 week

Clay Cameron (shoulder) 2-3 weeks

Charlie Dixon (groin) 1-2 weeks

Karmichael Hunt (concussion) test

Jack Martin (shoulder) indefinite

Zack Smith (knee) indefinite

Seb Tape (hamstring) test

ON THE BLOCK: Not too many in this category, as there were many contributors in the Suns' win over Melbourne on Sunday. However, substitute Jack Hutchins gathered just four disposals when he came on during the fourth quarter. Despite his limited time on ground, he finished with a sub-par disposal efficiency of 50 per cent.

DEMONS NEARLY PINCH SUNS SCRAP

ON THE CUSP: It was not a great afternoon for the Suns' NEAFL side, which went down to Sydney by 100 points on Saturday. However, among the team's best players were, again, Tom Murphy and Tim Sumner. Jesse Lonergan, Seb Tape and Daniel Gorringe, who have been hampered by injuries over the first few weeks of the season, all played in the NEAFL too. Nathan Bock is not too far away.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: Five weeks into the home-and-away season and Gold Coast still sits inside the top eight with a 3-2 record. Gary Ablett continues to lead this side superbly, while Tom Lynch and Sam Day — when they get their kicking boots on — will win games off their respective own boots one day. The Suns must prove how much they have progressed on Saturday, though, when they take on GWS at Metricon Stadium. A five-goal plus win is a necessity.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

GWS

INJURIES

Phil Davis (kidney) indefinite

Shane Mumford (knee) 1-2 weeks

Tim Mohr (knee) 2-4 weeks

Rhys Palmer (hamstring) 1-2 weeks

Sam Schulz (shoulder) 3 weeks

Dylan Shiel (quad) test

Lachie Whitfield (foot) 1-2 weeks

Callan Ward (concussion) test

Heath Shaw (hamstring) test

ON THE BLOCK: The Giants were outstanding in the first 15 minutes of the game against Adelaide, but couldn't convert their dominance around the ground into scoreboard pressure. From there, they fell away to the point the game was done and dusted by halftime. When playing their best, these brash young kids can take it up to anyone, but when they go to sleep things can get ugly. They lacked the composure of Heath Shaw across half-back and the trio of tall forwards — Jeremy Cameron, John Patton and Tom Boyd — didn't really get the supply to have an impact. Leon Cameron will place on emphasis on defence this week and anyone identified as not paying sufficient respect to this area of the game plan will be in danger.

RENDELL'S PREDICTION CLOSE TO A REALITY

ON THE CUSP: The Giants reserves had the bye this weekend, so fringe players like Dylan Addison, Jono O'Rourke, Jacob Townsend, Stephen Gilham, Matt Buntine and Andrew Phillips didn't have the opportunity to press their claims any further. Leon Cameron will be keen to add some experienced heads to the side and particularly in the back half of the ground. Gilham and Addison are a chance to come in, while Heath Shaw is expected to return after missing Round 5 with a minor hamstring strain. Dylan Shiel is a first team player, but will likely return via the NEAFL after missing several weeks with a quad strain.

ADAM BALDWIN'S FORECAST: GWS set the bar high with its Round 1 triumph against Sydney and while they Giants have played some good quarters since, they've hardly replicated the same form. The Melbourne game was a pass, but they had chances to win against St Kilda and the Western Bulldogs and didn't. Gold Coast presents another challenge this weekend, not only because the Suns are a quality young side, but because these two teams are expected to face off in big games in the coming years. The leger is 3-1 in Gold Coast's favour and GWS will need to string four quarters together and for the midfielders to give the forward line a chance to kick a score to win the game.

The Giants should welcome back Heath Shaw this week. Picture: Mark Kolbe Source: Getty Images

HAWTHORN

Jed Anderson (shoulder) test

Liam Shiels (AC joint) 3-4 weeks

Brad Sewell (hamstring) 1-2 weeks

Matt Spangher (ankle) 3-4 weeks

Brendan Whitecross (knee) indefinite

Alex Woodward (shoulder) test

ON THE BLOCK: Mitch Hallan did everything right once he came on after starting as the sub (six disposals at 100 per cent efficiency) but he didn't get much time to show what he can do. Ben Stratton played the whole match for the same number of disposals but Kyle Cheney is in the gun with Brian Lake's imminent return.

ON THE CUSP: Lake played his second game in the VFL on Saturday night and is set for a job on Jack Riewoldt. Some consolation for the Hawks after their Easter Monday loss is that the Box Hill Hawks defeated Geelong on Saturday night to keep top spot on the VFL ladder. Sam Grimley kicked four goals, Jon Ceglar dominated the ruck and Billy Hartung was named in the best.

AL PATON'S FORECAST: The Hawks will be keen to bury another curse (albet a relatively minor one) against Richmond on Sunday after losing their past two against the Tigers. A loss to Geelong was a small speed bump on a hugely impressive season. After Richmond an engagement with St Kilda is in the diary before a trip to Sydney to renew acquaintances with Lance Franklin.

THE TACKLE: SHOW SAINTS RESPECT

MELBOURNE

INJURIES

Jesse Hogan (back) 3-4 weeks

Viv Michie (jaw) 3-5 weeks

Luke Tapscott (hamstring) test

Dean Kent (calf) test

Jack Trengove (foot) season

ON THE BLOCK: A few Dees looked below the required AFL standard during their team's loss to Gold Coast on Sunday. Jordie McKenzie struggled to contain the masterful Gary Ablett and had only 10 possessions himself. Cam Pederson (nine disposals) and Neville Jetta (nine) also struggled to find the footy. Jack Watts kicked at 82 per cent efficiency, but only touched the ball 11 times.

NO STARS FOR COMEDY GOAL REVIEW

ON THE CUSP: Christian Salem gave his biggest push yet for an AFL debut, accumulating 34 disposals in a best-on-ground performance for Casey Scorpions in the VFL on Sunday. Mark Jamar played another game for Casey and finished with two goals, while fellow ruckman Max Gawn played his first VFL game in 2014 after being hampered by a hamstring injury. James Strauss and Mitch Clisby also impressed for the Scorpions to push their case for senior selection.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: While the Dees would have been disappointed to go down to the Suns, their never-say-die attitude would have encouraged fans. Every time the Suns looked to run away with the match, Melbourne responded on the scoreboard to stay in the match, even until the final minute. Ultimately, the experience and class of Gary Ablett was the difference. Chris Dawes is growing in confidence, highlighted by his haul of 2.4 from 17 touches and six inside-50s against the Suns. You feel, though, it could be a long night for the Dees against a rejuvenated Sydney at the MCG on Saturday night.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

NORTH MELBOURNE

INJURIES

Ben Brown (knee) 1 week

Tom Curran (foot) indefinite

Cam Delaney (foot) test

Taylor Garner (hamstring) test

Jamie McMillan (broken leg) 4 weeks

Andrew Swallow (Achilles) 1-3 weeks

Robbie Tarrant (lower leg) 1 week

Jack Ziebell (shoulder) test

ON THE BLOCK: Scott Thompson is set to miss a week after being reported for striking Travis Cloke. Daniel Currie can't afford to miss a beat at training this week with Majak Daw firing in the VFL. Currie struggled against the Magpies, collecting six disposals including a goal before being subbed out. Brad McKenzie failed to fire while Aaron Mullett lacked his customary run and carry. Substitute Ben Jacobs toiled hard for his 15 disposals.

SCOTT FORECASTS KANGAROOS SHAKE-UP

ON THE CUSP: All eyes on Jack Ziebell this week with the Kangaroos' enforcer to be put through his paces ahead of North's trip across the Nullarbor. Daw was best for Werribee, kicking five goals in the narrow loss to Port Melbourne. Robin Nahas, Mason Wood, Taylor Hine and Kieran Harper remain in contention, while Taylor Garner must prove he's overcome a hamstring complaint to make his return — most like through the VFL. Meanwhile, first-year defender Trent Dumont (draft pick No.30) was best afield for VFL affiliate North Ballarat, while rookie Tim McGenniss is doing everything right to earn his stripes.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Warning — the following forecast might contain information unpleasant to North Melbourne fans. History is against North Melbourne ahead of Saturday's crunch clash with Fremantle. The Kangaroos have lost nine of their past 10 games in Perth including the past four to the Dockers. Ziebell will add strength and leadership to the developing midfield, while Drew Petrie must do more than crunch packs if North is going to buck the trend. On a brighter note, North Melbourne also had 1-10 record at the SCG before knocking over the Swans recently. The Kangaroos must combine effort with skills and poise under pressure to avoid another embarrassing loss.

North Melbourne vice-captain Jack Ziebell in action. Picture: Yuri Kouzmin Source: News Corp Australia

PORT ADELAIDE

INJURIES

Chad Wingard (head/chest) test

Karl Amun (ankle) TBC

Angus Monfries (hamstring) 1 week

Jack Hombsch (hamstring) test

Jarrad Redden (knee) 4-5 weeks

Campbell Heath (shin) test

Sam Russell (hamstring) 4-5 weeks

Lewis Stevenson (toe) 6 weeks

Mason Shaw (wrist) 4-5 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Despite a few players occupying spots on the injury list, the Power are close to full-strength at the moment. And it will be hard to drop anyone from the side following a gutsy 14-point win against West Coast on Saturday. Aaron Young might be the unlucky one if any changes are made after he only managed six disposals and seven SuperCoach points as the sub.

POWER'S FITNESS POLICY PAYING OFF

ON THE CUSP: Angus Monfries, who is undoubtedly in the Power's best 22 players, will be monitored throughout the next week or two as he recovers from a hamstring injury. Port Adelaide's SANFL team takes on Woodville-West Torrens on Monday afternoon, with a handful of fringe Power hoping to regain their spot in the senior side. Forwards John Butcher and Cameron Hitchcock both staked their claims for senior selection a few weekends back, booting five goals each against Glenelg.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: Wins like the one Port Adelaide registered on Saturday night elevate sides into top-four contention. It was a dogged win, highlighted, again, by the Power's ability to run sides off their feet in the final term. Pacy recruits Jared Polec (27 disposals) and Matt White (19 and five inside-50s) continue to prove how important they are to Port's midfield. However, another massive test in Geelong awaits them on Sunday. The atmosphere at the Adelaide Oval will be electric.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

RICHMOND

INJURIES

Jake King (toe) 2-3 weeks

Matt Dea (hand) 1-2 weeks

Brett Deledio (Achilles) test

Aaron Edwards (knee) test

Chris Knights (knee soreness) 1 week

Ivan Maric (ankle) 2-3 weeks

Alex Rance (foot) test

Cadeyn Williams (shoulder) 1-2 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Matt Thomas is an interesting case. He again won the hard ball early on Thursday night but he was subbed out not long after halftime and the Tigers looked quicker and more lively with Nathan Gordon on the field. Sam Lloyd was quiet after starting his career in a blaze of glory but should be safe while Shane Edwards got his season going with two late goals. Dylan Grimes isn't doing much wrong defensively but offers very little going the other way (averaging seven disposals a game this year) and could be in trouble when Alex Rance is fit.

TIGERS TAP INTO RUCK DILEMMA

ON THE CUSP: Top draft pick Ben Lennon is closing on an AFL debut after picking up 28 disposals and 16 marks playing across half-back in the VFL. Jake Batchelor (30 touches) played his best game of the year while Matt McDonough was again prominent. Rookie Anthony Miles was the VFL outfit's top ball-winner but Ty Vickery kicked just one goal as the second-tier side went down to Williamstown by 70 points. Damien Hardwick said in his post-game press conference after the win against the Lions that Brett Deledio and Alex Rance could both play against the Hawks. Was he being optimistic?

AL PATON'S FORECAST: Anomaly or genuine bogey? Richmond has played Hawthorn once in each of the past two years and won both games, by 41 and 62 points. Sunday's clash at the MCG will be a massive test but an extra four days to prepare and the possible return of two key players will add to the confidence gained by a seven-goal win at the Gabba. That game wasn't pretty but the Tigers' produced some link-up play through the middle that hasn't been seen too often this season. A win would put the Tigers right back in the hunt — if Plough was still there you suspect this might be the match for which every player signs the Sherrin.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

ST KILDA

INJURIES

David Armitage (leg) 2 weeks

Sam Gilbert (foot) 4-6 weeks

Lewis Pierce (back) 4 weeks

Nathan Wright (broken leg) 10-12 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Seb Ross had only four touches after coming on late to replace Eli Templeton, who had only seven himself before putting on the sub vest. Hard to see any others being dropped on form although Josh Bruce could get a tap on the shoulder if Sam Fisher is ready to return. James Gwilt suffered a jarred back but should be right, but the news isn't as good for David Armitage who remains in hospital after suffering a freak gash to his knee courtesy of Patrick Dangerfield's boot studs a week ago.

ON THE CUSP: Fisher picked up 20 disposals and seven marks in his return match in the VFL and will be on the plane to Wellington, although the Saints say that doesn't necessarily mean he'll be in the 22 against Brisbane. Shane Savage, who was born in New Zealand and was used to promote the match during the pre-season, is a chance to return after 27 touches for Sandringham. Trent Dennis-Lane kicked four goals and Terry Milera two in the Zebras' 35-point win against North Ballarat, but the Saints are well served for small goalkickers.

AL PATON'S FORECAST: The "bottoming out" script is undergoing a hasty revision after the Saints' best win of the season. After playing the winless Lions at "home" in Wellington on Anzac Day St Kilda is likely to be safely in the top eight with a 4-2 record. After that things get tougher with a clash against the Hawks before home games against Carlton and Gold Coast leading into the bye. Alan Richardson won't want to look too far ahead but with champions firing at the top end of his list and the excitement of Jack Billings, Jack Newnes, Luke Dunstan and new shutdown king Tom Curren, St Kilda is providing a great value for money in 2014.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

SYDNEY SWANS

INJURIES

Adam Goodes (knee) test

Tom Mitchell (ankle) test

Alex Johnson (knee) season

Sam Reid (Achilles) TBC

Tommy Walsh (hamstring) 1-2 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Not too many this week after a more Sydney-like performance against Fremantle. But with a couple of big names on the cusp, a few Swans must make way at some stage. The two substitutes — Brandon Jack and Jake Lloyd — only managed 11 disposals between them.

THAT'S MORE LIKE IT, SWANS

ON THE CUSP: The returns of Kurt Tippett and Adam Goodes are imminent. Tippett kicked three goals and moved well during his 40 minutes for the Swans' NEAFL side on the weekend. Goodes is expected to start full training this week as well, but Tippett is more likely to come into consideration first. Despite a sub-par start to 2014, Tom Mitchell is too good to be on the sidelines for too long. Toby Nankervis continued his excellent NEAFL form, booting four goals in a best-on-ground performance on Saturday. Shane Biggs also impressed against Gold Coast's reserves side.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: That's better! The Swans regained their hard-nosed, team-orientated mojo against a quality Fremantle outfit. It would have made coach John Longmire thrilled to see the likes of Josh Kennedy, Rhyce Shaw and Ben McGlynn all make significant contributions. However, as Kennedy suggested in the post-match wash-up, his side must replicate that intensity and competitiveness every week. A good place to start is against Melbourne this Saturday.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

WEST COAST

INJURIES

Xavier Ellis (calf) test

Shannon Hurn (knee) 3-4 weeks

Mark LeCras (broken arm) 3-4 weeks

Beau Waters (shoulder) season

ON THE BLOCK: Xavier Ellis, who was plagued by calf issues during his time at Hawthorn, succumbed to another calf injury against Port Adelaide on Saturday. Skipper Darren Glass will happily accept a one-match ban for cleaning up Chad Wingard. Josh Hill produced another disappointing performance, failing to kick a goal from nine touches. Jamie Cripps managed only eight possessions.

ON THE CUSP: Sam Butler was switched from defence into the midfield for East Perth in the WAFL on Good Friday and impressed. Big man Scott Lycett was a dominant force up forward, booting 5.1 from 15 touches and eight marks. Plenty of young Eagles turned heads too, including Jeremy McGovern (20 possessions), Blayne Wilson (24) and Callum Sinclair (20). Tom Barass, who has been hampered by a hip injury so far this season, amassed 17 touches in just over a half in his first game of 2014.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: The Eagles had a golden opportunity to announce themselves and beat a quality side at home. They did not. While fitness was an issue — Port Adelaide overran Adam Simpson's men in the fourth quarter — the inaccuracy of Josh Kennedy and Jack Darling in front of goal was costly, with the key forwards finishing with 3.8 between them. The Eagles' fight and desire will be tested next Saturday when the team travels to Etihad Stadium to take on a rejuvenated Carlton. If they can rebound and win, a top-eight spot seems more realistic.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

WESTERN BULLDOGS

INJURIES

Jarrad Grant (foot) 2-3 weeks

Dale Morris (ankle) test

Daniel Pearce (knee) 4-8 weeks

Josh Prudden (knee) 2 weeks

Jordan Roughead (shoulder) 6 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Mitch Wallis had a day to forget against Carlton, gathering just nine disposals while allowing direct opponent Marc Murphy to return to form with 28 disposals and two goals. After copping plenty of elbows, hips and shoulders from Carlton opponents, Wallis was subbed out of the game. Liam Jones was held goalless from 10 disposals while Lin Jong only accumulated 10 too, but he is still learning.

ROUND 5: IF YOU DON'T MIND, UMPIRE!

ON THE CUSP: Dale Morris has served his one-game suspension, but he still has to overcome the ankle injury he suffered during the same tripping incident against GWS. In the VFL, Tory Dickson led the way in Footscray's forward line to boot five of his team's 13 goals. Livewire Mitch Honeychurch was named the Dogs' best player.

BEN WATERWORTH'S FORECAST: A reality check for the Dogs against the Blues after two straight victories. It is very difficult to win games when you concede seven goals and only kick three yourself in the first quarter. The positive aspect for the Dogs is there is room for improvement in many individuals, particularly Will Minson, Tom Liberatore and Robert Murphy. Next Sunday's game against Adelaide at Etihad Stadium turns is undoubtedly the Dogs' most important game of the season to date.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

United Blues limp to first win

Lachie Henderson kicked five goals to lead Carlton to its first win of the season. Picture: Michael Klein. Source: Michael Klein / News Corp Australia

MICK Malthouse's only recorded use of the corridor is to access his living room and as a venue to banish muffin-munching photographers.

Last night as besieged Carlton's leaders in Marc Murphy and Bryce Gibbs answered their baying critics, so too did 61-year-old Malthouse.

Malthouse hasn't survived long enough to be in sight of Jock McHale's record without using every bit of rat cunning and adaptability.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

As the Blues finally broke their 2014 drought, they did so by abandoning central tenets of Malthouse's three-decade old game plan.

In a freewheeling, high-scoring contest full of positives previously invisible at Visy Park, the Blues finally embraced that little-used patch of turf.

Jumping a Bulldogs side which just refused to die, the Blues roared up and down the corridor as if it was a German Autobahn.

Dale Thomas and Jarrad Waite celebrates a third quarter goal. Pic: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

The Blues did it without a hamstrung Chris Judd — who lasted just six minutes- and despite a Bulldog comeback that only quit in the final moments

Yet if the Bulldogs kept pushing the manner of the victory should only heighten the Blues' belief.

Senior assistant and Malthouse confidante Robert Wiley had said pre-match Malthouse had spent the week on the track relearning the key game plan fundamentals.

Yet instead of the stodgy, defence-based football of the last month the Blues looked a little like

Ed Curnow was outstanding on Tom Liberatore until a collision with a goalpost left him with a suspected broken leg. Pic: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

Brett Ratten's run-and-gun Carlton in a pre-Malthouse era.

That game plan saw Carlton 37 points up early in the third term, but as Malthouse would know it also kept the Dogs in this contest.

Continually they surged in a thrilling second half, pushing and testing Carlton's reserves.

Yet if Malthouse's defence did not have its usual host of midfield reinforcements it still stood up in a mighty test.

If Murphy ultimately delivered a two-fingered salute to his critics despite the close attentions of Mitch Wallis, it was Gibbs who started the domination.

Bryce Gibbs ignited the Blues in the first quarter. Picture: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

He found himself at the fall over every contested ball, sprinting from defence to hit up Carlton's forward targets with a 10-possession first quarter.

As a result recalled forward Jarrad Waite and swingman Lachie Henderson feasted on the quicksilver delivery with five combined first-quarter goals.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

From there confidence coursed through the veins of every Carlton player's veins.

Dale Thomas was urgent and polished, Warnock as huge in the ruck, Henderson (five goals) presented all day, and Andrew Walker relentlessly charged off half back

For a time the Dogs just kept in touch through Luke Dahlhaus's nose for a goal and Ryan Griffen's pulsating running power in his best game for the year.

Chris Judd lasted just six minutes before a hamstring injury ended his night. Picture: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

The critical moment came 10 minutes into the second term after three early Dogs goals to drag back the margin to only two goals.

Bulldog Jack Macrae surged into goal but his dribbling effort from close-range missed by a mile.

Seconds later the Blues transferred the ball to Chris Yarran who goaled on the run to put the margin to 17 points, instead of the six from a Macrae goal.

Even when they pushed again late they could get no closer than three goals as the Blues somehow steadied the ship.

Carlton coach Mick Malthouse just before quarter time. Pic: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

The Dogs might be on the march, but they aren't yet the kind of side that can win without an even performance.

As much as Griffin, Dahlhaus, Macrae won possessions at will, too many prime movers didn't come to the party.

Robert Murphy was shut out of the game, Tom Liberatore was smashed by Ed Curnow and Will Minson was soundly beaten early by Robert Warnock.

With players like the highly encouraging Marcus Bontempelli and Ling Jong finding their feet — and tagger Wallis not contributing any offensive drive — they just couldn't keep up.

Chris Scott or Alastair Clarkson wouldn't have been quivering with fear at the Blues yesterday, but finally this grand old club again has a pulse.

18.49 | 0 komentar | Read More

Vettel ignores team orders yet again

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

WORLD champion Sebastian Vettel denied sparking another Red Bull team orders row after he appeared to ignore an instruction during the Chinese Grand Prix on Sunday.

Vettel grumpily replied, "Tough luck" when told to yield to his teammate Daniel Ricciardo, who was closing fast in fifth, after the first round of pitstops.

Ricciardo eventually passed two laps later and finished fourth, 21 seconds ahead of Vettel in fifth. Mercedes' Lewis Hamilton was the winner.

But despite his initial reaction, Vettel insisted he did give way to Ricciardo when he realised the Australian had more pace.

Ricciardo and Vettel lock eyes as they stand either side of Hamilton after Chinese GP qualifying Source: AP

"I did move over," Vettel told reporters. "Initially I didn't understand (the request) because we were on the same tyres.

"At that stage Daniel was on a different strategy so, yeah, I moved over. I could see more and more towards the end of the race that I just didn't have the pace ... In the end there was no point in holding him back."

Ricciardo has been consistently quicker than Vettel this season in an unexpected challenge for the German, who has won the last four world titles but currently lies fifth in the standings.

Vettel's initial response over the radio came when he was informed that Ricciardo, who was on the same tyres, was behind only because he had pitted earlier.

Vettel has previously ignored orders, most famously when he overtook then teammate Mark Webber to win the 2013 Malaysian Grand Prix despite being told to hold second position.

Ricciardo after finally getting in front of Vettel at the Shanghai International Circuit. Source: Getty Images

However, two weeks ago in Bahrain, he moved over without complaint for Ricciardo, who was on quicker, softer tyres.

Vettel's version of events on Sunday was backed up by team boss Christian Horner.

"Look, at that stage Seb was on the same tyres and he wants to race," Horner said. "But he was going through the tyres quicker so he's obviously moved out of the way and let his teammate through.

"From a team point of view we always want to get the best result for the team that we can. And Seb's done the right thing today."

Horner added that he was much more concerned about finding the reasons behind Vettel's lack of pace.

"More important for us is to try to understand what Seb is struggling with at the moment," he said.

18.49 | 0 komentar | Read More

Things looking a little rosier for Daisy

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

CARLTON recruit Dale Thomas says the Blues will take real confidence from their first win of the season after a week of headlines at Visy Park.

Thomas took another step forward with a 16-possession game played deep in defence, aware the critics have been quick to jump on his performances.

UNITED BLUES LIMP TO FIRST WIN

He said the Blues knew the football world had come at them in recent weeks, but believed the season would turn if they improved their efforts.

"It was a good win and we will take a bit from that. That's football, when you play well there are people who pat you and when its starts to go the other way there are twice as many people who jump on your back and chop you down,'' he said.

"We know that, we don't buy into too much of that bull**** at the club. The Essendon game we lost some confidence but we will learn a bit from tonight and take some confidence from it. 1-4 is better than 0-5."

Dale Thomas had 16 possessions in his first win as a Blue. Photo by Michael Dodge Source: Getty Images

Thomas said he was happy to be gradually improving under Malthouse despite averaging only 18 disposals a game.

"Week to week it's starting to come. I played a fair bit deep down back tonight so my possession rate wasn't as high but along with the rest of the boys the effort around the ball was fantastic and if we can turn the ball over at the source and get it going into our forward line the way we did it gives you a chance to win games and fortunately tonight we did that.

"I will be the first to say I am not setting the world on fire, but at the moment I am happy to be out there playing my role for the team and happy to be out there playing footy again.

"Obviously getting to know how the boys play and the boys know how I play, that is taking a bit of time.

"There are no excuses from my front. I will cop my whack when I deserve it."

AFL Round 5. Western Bulldogs v Carlton at Etihad Stadium. Bulldogs coach Brendan McCartney. Pic: Michael Klein. Saturday April 19, 2014. Source: News Corp Australia

Western Bulldogs coach Brendan McCartney admitted his side had blown a late chance to win the game, but knew they did not deserve the victory.

He said he was "pretty optimistic" Dale Morris (ankle/suspension) would be back against Adelaide next week, with his Dogs now 15th after missing a chance to vault into the top eight.

"It was a bit of a nervousness to snatch at it and rush it and when we missed that (Stewart Crameri) set shot they were jumping for joy, the Carlton boys. It was like we have dodged a bullet,'' McCartney said.

"But I don't believe we deserved to be that close. They outplayed us, they were good around the ball, they played really well. They deserved the four points and they deserved to win the game."

Marcus Bontempelli is tackled by Ed Curnow. Photo by Michael Dodge Source: Getty Images

He said he was happy with no. 4 selection Marcus Bontempelli's 14-possession debut performance, content that he is a hard worker who will continually maximise his talent.

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

Judd injury won’t leave Blues hamstrung

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

CARLTON will have to resurrect its finals hopes without superstar Chris Judd after hurting his hamstring in the Blues' first win of the season over the Western Bulldogs last night.

Judd's nightmare season continued when the dual Brownlow Medallist grabbed his right hamstring and pulled up lame only six minutes into his comeback from an Achilles injury.

UNITED BLUES LIMP TO FIRST WIN

Judd, who came on the ground as the substitute late in the third term, is expected to miss at least three weeks, sidelining the champion ball-winner for Saturday's clash against his old side West Coast.

Chris Judd injures his hamstring after being pushed by Stewart Crameri as he kicked Photo by Michael Dodge Source: Getty Images

The injury will further fuel speculation the 30-year-old is in the final season of a glittering career and marred the club's spirited response to a winless first month of the season.

Coach Michael Malthouse said he felt for Judd after his latest injury setback but said the midfielder's interrupted preparation had nothing to do with last night's blow.

"It was just an overstride and probably most players would have got it, or certainly players who have got that sort of pace," Malthouse said.

"One thing we won't do is get locked out and say we can't win with him or without him.

"We all know what a great player he has been and he has been missing all year, really."

Ed Curnow cleans up the point post when he is tackled by Liam Picken. Pic: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

The Blues played with greater pace and freedom in the 28-point win at Etihad Stadium but Malthouse denied the game plan for last night' match had changed "one inch" from their first four losses.

Rather, Malthouse praised the Blues' grit and determination to stave off the Dogs second-half comeback with only one fit man on the bench, after losing Judd and Ed Curnow to a last-term knee injury.

Ed Curnow on crutches after game. Pic: Michael Klein. Source: News Corp Australia

Malthouse said the club's tortured start to the season, suffering four-straight defeats for the first time since 1989, may have helped galvanise the playing group.

"When you've lost games, you have doubt," Malthouse said.

"But also when you've lost games and you keep getting back up, it strengthens you.

"I felt today we were mentally prepared and mentally strong when we needed to be and that may have been an offshoot of losing four (games).

"I'm not sure, it's immeasurable. But my understanding of the game and sport in general is if you lose games like this there becomes a consolidation of the group and the mind.

"Today we were able to push through — one) against a good football side, and two) despite a lack of rotation availability."

AFL Round 5. Western Bulldogs v Carlton at Etihad Stadium. Chris Judd talks with Robert Warnock after game. Pic: Michael Klein. Saturday April 19, 2014. Source: News Corp Australia

Malthouse described ruckman Robbie Warnock's game as the best of his career and said his team's improved ball use was crucial helping his key forwards capitalise on the scoreboard.

Big men Lachie Henderson and Jarrad Waite kicked eight goals between them.

"(There were) Less turnovers and more opportunities and we took the opportunities," he said.

"It's handy when you've got three forwards who can actually catch the football and that builds the confidence in itself."

18.48 | 0 komentar | Read More

‘Time for big decisions at Sydney FC’

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

POST mortems are never easy, especially after such a heartbreaking end to your season.

Still, you can't dodge the tough decisions for too long and Sydney FC have some big issues to face over the next few days and weeks.

The moves Sydney FC chief executive Tony Pignata make now will not only shape the direction of the team, but also football in this city.

The Sky Blues were brave against Melbourne Victory in Friday night's elimination final. It's always tough to go interstate for a finals match, knowing you have to win in a hostile environment. That's why a top-two place is so crucial.

Gui Finkler's winner in injury time ended Sydney's season and potentially Alessandro Del Piero's time in the A-League. I think it's fair to say the Sky Blues have underachieved in the two years they have had the Italian maestro.

Time to reflect. Source: Getty Images

He was dispossessed for the first goal to Archie Thompson and he has struggled at times this year with the pace of the A-League. Then you see the exquisite touch and vision and it reminds you how blessed we have been to have Del Piero in our game.

To do what he has done at the age of 39 shows he was one of the greatest footballers the world has seen because this isn't an easy league.

The big question — the only question — is can Sydney win the championship with him? It will be an emotional decision because he has brought so much to the city in terms of profile, everyone loves him and he can still be a match-winner on his day.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

However, teams such as Brisbane, Central Coast, the Wanderers and Melbourne Victory play at a tempo that Sydney fail to match at times. Del Piero, for all his talent, struggles to track back and this season he was hampered by soft tissue injuries.

These football issues have to be weighed against his value as a true marquee star.

If Del Piero's time is up — and he has indicated he wants to play on — it has been a privilege to watch him play in Australia. If you had asked me 20 years ago if a player of ADP's pedigree would come to our league, and embrace it so passionately, I would never have believed you.

Of course, no matter what happens at Sydney, fans will have the opportunity to say thank you when he leads the All Stars against Juventus in August.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

Frank Farina's future is the other issue hanging heavily over Sydney. He needed a top-four finish to guarantee a contract for next season. The Sydney front office isn't known for stability, so who knows what they will do.

Farina did a good job this year under difficult circumstances. It must be extremely difficult to coach a team under so much uncertainty and he handled all the questions about his future with great dignity.

His team was so brave against Victory and they clearly played for the coach. You could never question their heart or spirit.

Will Frank Farina be given another year at Sydney FC? Source: Getty Images

The club has now come to the end of a two-year cycle, they have to sign new players and also decide if Frank's the man to build the new era. I'd like to see him stay.

Finally, if fans want a glimpse of the future, it was there in Terry Antonis.

He is getting better all the time and, at 20, I hope he doesn't go to Europe too soon. His dream of playing Serie A will always be there, but he will leave as a better player if he stays in Sydney for at least one more season.

It's exciting when young talent comes through and you can understand a player wanting it all right now.

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player.

Yet, too many times, we have seen a player leave the A-League and get lost in Europe. You almost need to send a search party out to find them.

The last thing Australian football needs is what happened to Tommy Rogic at Celtic repeating itself with Antonis. He missed so much game time this year with a thigh injury, he needs miles in his legs. He will get that here.

A finals spot was a good result when you consider their early-season problems. But a club the size of Sydney has to aim higher than fifth place.

Sydney should be a club of ambition — and those tough decisions have to be made now.

18.49 | 0 komentar | Read More

Izzy’s early heroics enough for Tahs

Israel Folau celebrates his try after just 30 seconds against the Bulls at Allianz Stadium. Source: Mark Metcalfe / Getty Images

ISRAEL Folau marked his return from injury with the only try of the match as the NSW Waratahs edged the Bulls 19-12 at Allianz Stadium.

Folau took less than 30 seconds to make his mark, running on to an inside ball from Adam Ashley-Cooper to score under the posts.

That was as good as it got for the home side, who had to make do with the rest of their points from the boot of Bernard Foley, who kicked a conversion and four penalties to lead the Waratahs to a gritty victory.

MATCH CENTRE: Full scores, stats and video highlights

Relive all the action from the Waratahs v Bulls clash with our match blog below

18.49 | 0 komentar | Read More